Secrets and Hope in Our Mad World

Early in 2017 I read George Marshall’s book ‘Don’t Even Think About It: Why We are Wired Not to Think About Climate Change’ and I decided I would think about it. And I would read about it. Then I would write about it.

I write as a 'non-expert' and I'm hoping that your comments will help me to see whether the insights I've

gained make sense, whether the conclusions stack up and whether it's realistic for me to start feeling

hopeful about the future .

March 26th - The Holy Mantra: Growth


 Even those with only a very limited interest in politics must have noticed that the first priority of politicans (except of course the Greens), the mantra which straddles the political parties, is that  'economic growth'  is crucial if the capitalist system on which our very lives have come to depend is to continue and flourish. Of course even a child can see that continual physical growth is impossible on a finite planet.

David Harvey:
‘Continuity of flow in the circulation of capital is very important. The process cannot be interrupted without incurring losses. There are also strong incentives to accelerate the speed of circulation.  Those who can move faster through the various phases of
capital circulation accrue higher profits than their competitors.  Speed-up nearly always pays off in higher profits.  Innovations which help speed things up are much sought after[1].’

‘Growth’ is seen by many as a basic flaw in the very nature of capitalism. Marx believed that capitalism, in its quest for higher profits and new markets,  inevitably contains ‘the seeds of its own destruction.’

Similarly, Tim Jackson[2] sees growth as the profound dilemma faced by society:
‘To resist growth is to risk economic and social collapse. To pursue it relentlessly is to endanger the ecosystems on which we depend for long-term survival ….. for the most part, this dilemma goes unrecognised in mainstream policy. It is only marginally more visible as a public debate.’


I've still not quite got to the nub of the problem - just why is growth essential to the capitalist system?   I'll see what I can find out about that.





[1] David Harvey op cit
[2] Tim Jackson op cit

No comments:

Post a Comment

Good to have your feedback. Thanks for commenting.